Stretchin' Out the Roast pt. 2

 In part 1 of Stretchin' Out the Roast we looked at the effect of stretching out the time and development between 1st and 2nd crack during the roast. The greatest effect was on the perceived acidity and the type of sweetness in the cup from malt to candy, then fruit and  into bittersweet-cocoa-type sweetness. In this article we look at the effect of stretching out the 1st crack itself and how that changes the sweetness, body, and acidity in the finished roast.

What is happening during  1st crack? The coffee expands and begins to release moisture, but more importantly it is when caramelization begins. This is important mostly because if caramelization stalls you can develop baked flavors in the cup - harsh cereal notes with straw and sometimes corn-like flavors. This makes the attempt to stretch out this part of the roast a little tricky, since you want to make sure that it never dips below the temperatures where caramelization occurs - between 340° and 400° INTERNAL bean temperature. Depending on your probe and roasting environment, this could be a reading of around 380°-415°, but a good rule of thumb is to just be sure not to let the crack itself stop or let it get below the temperature at which the 1st crack began.

I chose once again to use a Bourbon coffee from Rwanda for this experiment. A coffee that has some delicate floral and citrus features, but also has a range of sweetness with a potential for a balanced body and clear acidity. I also used the Probat PRE-1Z electric sample roaster again because of the control it gives the user with repeatibility of results.

The end point for each roast was approximately 30 seconds after the last audible crack.  I manipulated each roast with adjustments to air flow. For the first roast I made no adjustment to airflow, allowing the first crack to roll right through. For the second I increased air flow about 15 seconds earlier, then on the third roast about 30 seconds earlier, and so on.

I did 5 roasts, with the 3rd roast actually stalling. Since I tasted the baked effects of the stalling on my first round of cupping, I did not include it in the panel cuppings. 


The Particulars:   Coffee: Rwanda Karengera

Roast 1
Start: 320
Yellow: 5:20
1st C: 8:05
1st C end: 9:12
End: 9:37


Roast 2
Start: 320
Yellow: 5:24
1st C: 8:04
1st C end: 9:27
End: 9:50


Roast 3
Start: 320
Yellow: 5:18
1st C: 7:52
1st C end: stalled - 9:40 ish
End: 10:26


Roast 4
Start: 320
Yellow: 5:10
1st C: 7:27
1st C end: 9:55
End: 10:20

Roast 5
Start: 320
Yellow: 5:14
1st C: 7:44
1st C end: 9:44
End: 10:06

My tasting notes from these cups, excluding Roast 3:
Roast 1: Body: clean, condensed,Sweetness: mid palate, not so much in the finish, Acidity: tea like, dry, center
Roast 2: Body: sheer, Sweetness: nice through finish, Acidity: mild
Roast 4 : Body: more syrupy, Sweetness: very honey sweet through finish, Acidity: peak in the middle, even some tang at the sides of the palate
Roast 5:  Body: broad, big, Sweetness: marshmallow, sugar sweetness, Acidity: not as bright as the other coffees, but some in the back and finish

The first panel that I put these coffees in front of was a panel of untrained/inexperienced cuppers. Roast 4 was the universal favorite. As you will note, roast 4 actually has a longer 1st crack than roast 5; almost 2:30 mins compared to 2 mins exactly.  With more experienced cuppers, Roast 5 was the favorite. With these longer roasts, the mouthfeel was more full and tactile which created a longer and sweeter finish, and in the case of Roast 4 it also allowed for a more expressive acidity.

 Roast 1 was their second favorite of both panels, with a few people stating that there were aspects to Roast 1 that they liked more than either longer Roast.  It had the clearest and brightest acidity. It was sweet, but not through the short and dry finish. There was an overall condensed feel to the cup with everything right in the middle of the palate. This roasting style could lend itself rather nicely to a pour-over brewing method and I could see using a coffee roasted in this way being used in a component of a blend as an accent, perhaps even a blend with the same coffee roasted more like Roasts 4 and 5. 

The coffee that no one picked was Roast 2. I personally found it to be fairly mild  with muted acidity and a sheer mouthfeel. Compared to every other roast, the cup was just generally flat.

A more syrupy mouthfeel is related to the perception of particular carbohydrates that are released in greater levels with the stretching out of first crack. Stretching out the 1st crack did not have much effect on the sweetness of the coffee.  For part 3 of Stretchin' Out the Roast, I will be looking at stretching out the drying stage before the 1st crack begins.

part 3 is coming soon.....

part 3 is coming soon.....

pt. 3

Really enjoyed part 1 and 2 I'd be really interested to read your opinions on strectching out the drying stage before 1st crack in a stretchin out the roast pt. 3! any plans on putting that together anytime soon?

Thank you

Thank's for the hint ;)

I'll try next time :)

stretchin out the roast on a Behmor

It seems possible to stretch different parts of a roast in a Behmor. I have not tried this so I am not sure of the effects either on the roast or on the machine. One thing to try is opening the door to reduce the heat, and even add a bit of a fan to increase air flow (with door open). You just do not want the roast to stall, so it may take experimentation to get it right.

 I'm going to try this out

 I'm going to try this out next week. I've had 1C go 2:00 on a 1lb roast, so hopefully with some air and heat adjustment I can stretch it out longer. (using an 8oz charge weight)

Stretchin out the roast

I am considering buying a Behmor 1600.  Can I stretchout the roast with that machine?


Thanks OB 

With a Behmor ?

Hi, Thank's for this analyse it's helpfull for us to improve our roast ;)

Do you have an idee on how to do that with a Behmor ?

Thank's again,



Degree vs. Time

Just a quick question. You said you stopped the roast approx 30 seconds after the end of each 1st crack. Was the actual degree of roast the same for each roast or was this a variable as well as stretching out the time?

Degree vs Time

The degree of roast is the same - city plus-ish - but this experiment basically showed that the way you control first crack has a big impact on the final cup.